Indianapolis, IN – A 30-year-old man has been arrested following an argument over a takeout meal that escalated into an armed robbery on the near east side of Indianapolis earlier this month, according to the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department (IMPD). Authorities say the dispute led to assault, a gun being fired, and the theft of personal items, though no fatalities were reported.
Incident Overview
IMPD reports that just after 8 p.m. on January 9, officers responded to a local hospital following a report of a robbery with injury. The incident occurred in the 800 block of N Gray Street, where detectives learned that the victim had an argument with his roommate, later identified as Davante Payne, over a leftover takeout meal.
The disagreement reportedly centered on a catfish and French fry meal. Payne allegedly demanded $10, while the victim offered $3, leading to a violent confrontation.
Assault and Gunfire
During the dispute, Payne allegedly assaulted his roommate by kicking him on the left side of the head “like he was punting a football” and hitting him on the head and shoulder with a miniature baseball bat, which ultimately broke during the attack. Payne is also reported to have fired one shot in the victim’s bedroom.
“Payne reportedly took the roommate’s cell phone and keys during the incident,” IMPD said in a news release.
Investigators later located Payne riding a bicycle using GPS monitoring, noting that he appeared to have a handgun in his coat pocket. The firearm is believed to be the same one used during the incident.
Arrest and Charges
Payne, who was under GPS monitoring for probation in another case, has previous convictions for possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon. He initially complied with officers’ verbal commands but later resisted arrest, requiring the use of a Taser before being taken into custody.
He faces the following preliminary charges:
- Armed robbery
- Kidnapping
- Possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon
- Criminal recklessness
Evidence and Investigation
Authorities conducted a search of Payne’s residence, recovering additional evidence related to the incident. The investigation revealed that Payne had used a handgun during the confrontation and had taken the victim’s personal belongings. Officials are reviewing all evidence as the case moves through the legal process.
Public Safety Context
IMPD officials emphasized the dangers of escalating disputes into violence, even over seemingly minor disagreements. The department urges residents to seek help or mediation in conflicts and to avoid taking matters into their own hands, especially when weapons are involved.
Conclusion
A disagreement over a leftover catfish meal escalated into a serious armed robbery for which Davante Payne has been arrested and charged. The case highlights the potential severity of roommate disputes when firearms are involved. Share your experiences in the comments below.
